PSYCHOLOGY OF MARKETING  /  Psychological effects

All-natural effect

Why people trust products labeled as natural more than synthetic alternatives and how to apply this bias to your marketing strategy.

December 19, 2024 5 min read
Presented by STACKED MARKETER PRO
All-natural effect
FROM THE CREW

Hey 👋 The Crew here.

You’d probably agree that even marketing brains need to rest from time to time.

So after this issue, we’ll take a short holiday break and be back in your inboxes on Thursday, January 9th.

This is the last Psychology of Marketing you’ll read this year—so don’t skim it.

And of course, enjoy your holidays!

Reading time: 4 minutes, 40 seconds

New to Psychology of Marketing? Join us for free 🤝

Sponsored by STACKED MARKETER PROSTACKED MARKETER PRO

428 marketers just revealed what they’re prioritizing for 2025. Want to see how you compare?

We surveyed 428 Stacked Marketer readers—professionals just like you—to find out how they feel about budgets, salaries, and trends like AI.

Their insights and responses are invaluable if you’re planning for 2025—not the kind of stuff you’ll find with a Google search.

Inside the State of Online Marketing 2025 Report, you’ll discover:

  • Which platforms are dominating marketing budgets, plus the surprising channels marketers are planning to use next year.
  • The unexpected ways teams are leveraging AI to do more with limited resources.
  • Where marketers see major budget shifts coming in 2025.

You’ll also get a sense for salary trends, team structures, growth opportunities, and more.

In other words, exclusive insights that give you a clear view of where the industry is heading so you can prepare for it.

Want to make smarter decisions about where to invest your resources next year?

See what other savvy marketers are planning for 2025.

You know what has a nice ring to it? A product made with “natural ingredients.”

In a recent study, a group of researchers asked participants to choose between natural and synthetic products in various situations, such as eating a potentially stomach-upsetting chocolate bar.

In all cases, the majority of participants picked the natural option. They didn’t even bother to check the label or see whether the option was actually betterfor them!

Sounds familiar? That’s because you’ve probably seen brands leveraging this bias millions of times.

It’s called the all-natural effect, and it’s the common fallacy in which we tend to equate products perceived as “natural” with being safer, healthier, or environmentally friendly.

… Even though that’s not always true.

Beauty products slap on “all-natural” labels, implying they’re better for your hair or skin.

Consumables, especially food and beverage brands, do the same.

But ethics matter here. You don’t want to claim something is natural just because some ingredients are pure.

Also, some brands will intentionally try to mix natural with other buzzwords like “organic” or “vegan”—even when they don’t necessarily apply. Be careful.

Leveraging the all-natural bias for your own marketing—ethically, of course—is usually obvious: Just make sure you mention it somewhere in your ads.

So we’ll leave that tip out and focus on the not-so-obvious ways to use it instead.

Three ways to leverage the all-natural effect

01

Include elements of nature in your brand voice

Tip: You own the power to drive customers to subconscious connections using only words.

And since our mind looks favorably to anything that’s related to nature, we can play with semantics and use nature-related words instead of their counterparts for greater impact.

The word natural can often be a substitute for simplicity.

Like an app that allows you to manage finances in “a natural way,” for example. Or how your course helps the learner master the ability to “sell naturally.”

Some brands go as far as to make their entire branding revolve around natural elements, even if they don’t have much to do with nature.

Like sprout, for example:

And of course, there’s Apple, Blackberry, and Cotopaxi—a brand named after a volcano.

Even if your company doesn’t use a natural element in the name, you can still name a feature, a new line, a course “level,” or a new product line after it.

02

Draw visual inspiration from outdoors

Have you ever wondered why people say “stop and smell the flowers”?

It’s because we have an inborn preference for all things natural. They don’t tell you to stop and smell the perfume, right?

A 2013 study explored “attention restoration theory,” which suggests that nature restores focus and reduces stress.

The study found that ads featuring pleasant nature scenes evoke positive emotions and lead to better memory recall compared to other types of visuals.

… Which implies that you should blend visual natural elements in your ads, too.

The automotive industry usually does this in their promotions because the vast outdoors is associated with freedom and revitalization:

03

Highlight natural origins in manufacturing

Just because the final product isn’t natural doesn’t mean your consumers won’t appreciate knowing that your raw materials are.

You can emphasize that the materials or components used in the product have a natural, sustainable, or minimally processed origin—even if the product is far removed from nature.

You can do this in various ways depending on the industry:

  • Highlight the origin of materials. Wood, metal, glass, textile, etc. create a “natural” narrative.
  • Pull the sustainability card. Words like renewable, naturally sourced, low-impact, crafted, and similar add credibility—especially with eco-conscious consumers.
  • Use phrases that note minimal processing. Phrases like “minimally refined,” or “free of chemicals” can make your product feel “pure.”

Fairphone is a smartphone manufacturer whose entire branding revolves around “natural origins” when it comes to manufacturing tech:

IKEA highlights its furniture is made using “FSC-certifed wood,” for instance, while Allbirds prides itself on sugarcane-based foam or eucalyptus tree fibers in their shoes.

They all sound appealing, don’t they?

CLICKWORTHY

PAID GIGS: Get paid up to $600/hr to give marketing feedback! It sounds too good to be true? It’s not. Wynter needs your help. All you need is a LinkedIn, a job title, and a marketing brain. Apply here.*

MARKETING: Get one gift every day from now until Christmas. Marketing ideas, templates, insights, campaigns to send for instant ROI, and more. All in Moosend’s Advent Calendar. Sign up for free to get daily gifts here.*

BEHAVIOR:According to Pew Research Center, 46% of US teenagers are online “almost constantly.” 73% use YouTube daily, 60% use TikTok and Instagram, and 55% open up Snapchat every day. That’s a lot of video consumption. Will this trend continue as they age?

TIKTOK:The drama continues. Members of the House Committee on the Chinese Communist Party are urging Apple and Google to prepare for the US TikTok ban. ByteDance has until January 19th to hand over control of the app, or it could be removed from US app stores.

META: If Instagram was an animal it could be a cow. Cash cow, to be precise. Because according to reports, the app makes up more than half of Meta’s US ad revenue. Also, the combined revenue share from Explore, Reels, and Threads could rise 9.6% in 2025. Wow.

ICYMI, last time we looked at the Anchoring Effect.

The “Great outdoor” Crew

*This is a sponsored post.

Get the next psychology effect in your inbox.

Receive cutting-edge, science-driven marketing insights and tips every Thursday, for free.

Keep Reading