Happy Thursday.
If you’ve ever rewritten the same headline 14 times, you’re legally part of The Crew now. Welcome!
Talking about group identity…
Reading time: 5 minutes, 02 seconds
Skip the AI hype. Get 5+ hours of practical use cases from Meta, Google, and AWS — free
Most AI events oversell the future and underdeliver on the present. We’re trying something different.
We’re co-hosting AI Skills Conf, a free virtual conference where speakers from Meta, Google, AWS, Scale AI, and Bolt show you what’s actually working in 2026.
A taste of the agenda:
- Build your AI Chief of Staff from scratch — memory, projects, and daily briefs
- The 2026 AI tool stack for founders and small-business owners, the panel we’re moderating
- AI ROI reality check: which use cases are delivering business value
- How non-developers are shipping production apps with AI
The lineup: 30 speakers, 5,000+ attendees, 5+ hours of hands-on insights.
Mark your calendar: May 14 — 8 AM PT / 11 AM ET / 4 PM BST / 5 PM CET, live on Zoom.
Identity Threat
Ever skipped buying something because it felt too “mom-coded,” too “dad-bod,” or too “try-hard gamer”?
That’s Social Identity Threat doing its quiet work on your wallet.
Researchers White and Argo (2009) found that when a part of who we are gets subtly attacked, we start avoiding products linked to that identity, just to protect our self-worth.
In their studies, women exposed to articles questioning female intellect suddenly rated female-coded products more negatively. Same product. Different self.
This only happens to people with low collective self-esteem, meaning people who don’t strongly identify with the group.
Those with high collective self-esteem do the opposite. They double down.
Marketers who understand this lever, and when not to pull it, can shift purchase behavior in ways that feel almost invisible to the consumer.
Three ways to leverage Identity Threat
1) Threaten the old identity, sell the new one
Make who your customer used to feel uncomfortable, then position your product as the upgrade.
Nutrafol’s “Under Every Hat, There’s a Comeback” campaign does exactly this. The hat, a shield for hair loss insecurity, becomes the symbol of the old, avoidant identity.
The man hiding under the hat is passive. The man taking Nutrafol is reclaiming control.
The old identity is something to grow out of. Literally.
2) Build collective self-esteem into your brand, not just awareness
White and Argo found that customers high in collective self-esteem (CSE) stayed loyal to identity-linked brands even under threat.
If your audience feels good about their identity, they’ll stay loyal to your brand even when things get bumpy. Collective self-esteem is the shield.
Glossier built its early community not by selling makeup, but by affirming a specific identity: women who like skincare-first, minimalist beauty and don’t want to be told they need more.
Their “Skin first, makeup second” positioning validated a self-image already forming in their audience.
When competitors attacked the “no-makeup” aesthetic as lazy, Glossier customers didn’t flinch.
They’d already been told, repeatedly, that their choice was valid. That’s identity armor, and it converts into retention.
3) Don’t threaten the identity you’re trying to sell to
Classic marketing mistake: mocking the exact group holding the credit card.
Low-CSE members of that group will quietly dissociate, and sales drop.
When Peloton launched its infamous “The Gift That Gives Back” ad in 2019, it accidentally threatened the identity of the very women it was selling to, implying they needed fixing.
Stock dropped 9% in two days. The ad didn’t affirm fitness-minded women. It suggested they were inadequate without the bike.
Contrast this with Alo Yoga, which sells premium activewear by celebrating who the wearer already is, never suggesting they need rescuing from a lesser version of themselves.
Be smart when picking your battles.
Do you know what ChatGPT says about your company right now?
RankScience ran the test for 50 companies.
34 of them were either missing from AI answers entirely or only mentioned in passing without being recommended.
AI platforms decide which brands to name, and most businesses have never checked whether they made the list. The AI Visibility Snapshot shows you where you stand.
#Section
MARKETING: When your visuals and text compete for attention, your social media posts suffer. Reports say that aligning their messaging can boost engagement and “de-overwhelm” your audience. So start working on reducing that cognitive load… yesterday.
SOCIAL MEDIA: X launched a standalone chat app promising encryption, no ads, and no tracking. Researchers spotted holes in that story before the launch news cooled, with evidence suggesting X could read your messages. Oof.
PINTEREST: Couples are done with traditional, and Pinterest has the data to prove it. Speakeasy venues, opalescent palettes, and bold bridal headwear define the 2026 wedding moment. Study what resonates in niche communities before it goes mass.
META: Forget age brackets. Life stage is the real predictor. Meta and BAMM Global surveyed nearly 10,000 people across eight markets and found that major milestones like marriage or a new baby drive purchase intent up to 26 percentage points higher than age alone ever could.
YOUTUBE: Precisify’s report found that ad recall on YouTube beats TikTok, Facebook, and Netflix for both Gen Z and Millennials over 50% for each group. With 83% of Gen Z and 78% of Millennials using the platform daily, long-form placements may deserve a bigger budget cut.
ICYMI, last time we looked at the Optimism Bias.
The “Who Am I Again” Crew.
Interested in advertising in one of our newsletters?
Connect with over 100,000 of the world’s best marketers who read a newsletter by Stacked Marketer.
